Frozen Rainbow Chiffon Cake – DO NOT ATTEMPT!

This cake is amazing.  This cake is beautiful.  It’s like eating sorbet, but light and fluffy, like a cloud.  This cake will move people to sing your praises.  People will talk about this cake for weeks afterward.  This cake completely kicked my a**(as a teacher I have to bleep).

My best friend’s birthday was coming up and I happily volunteered to throw her a dinner party.  As we were discussing the menu while flipping through magazines I came across this cake in Martha Stewart Living.  “It’s perfect!” I exclaimed.  A five layer, multicolored, meringue masterpiece.  I skimmed the recipe, taking note of the ingredients and tools required.  I was up to the challenge!

Here is the magazine picture from August MSL:

The cake requires 5 different fruit purees which can be made up to two days in advance.  Each of the purees is then whisked in to meringue and frozen.  The whole frozen concoction is then slathered in Seven Minute Frosting, a marshmallowy, glossy, meringue frosting.

The cake was to be served on Sunday so I decided to make the purees on Friday, the frozen meringue layers on Saturday, and frost the cake on Sunday morning.  I was glad I took this approach considering this G** d**m thing took me the entire three days to create.

Friday.  Puree number one: blueberries and blackberries. Puree two: papaya. Three: apricot.  Four: strawberries and raspberries.  Five: kiwi.  Each puree is blended in the Cuisinart with lemon juice and then strained.  Translation: you have to wash the d*** Cusinart in between every one, not to mention get all the seeds and c**p out of the strainer each time.  Puree making time: two hours.

Saturday: You would think that you could make one giant batch of meringue and then divide it into 5 bowls.  No.  That would be too easy.  Martha felt that the texture just wouldn’t be right unless you made a separate meringue for each of the 5 layers.  I have heard people say that they think some of Martha’s recipes are purposely too complicated.  As though she wants to somehow make us feel just the tiniest bit inferior.  I never believed this until I attempted this cake.  Needless to say I made 5 different d**n meringues.  You have to beat the egg whites to frothy while heating sugar and water to 250 degrees, then add the sugar syrup to the egg whites in a slow, steady stream down the side of the mixing bowl.  Then you have to beat the whole thing on high until it becomes thick and glossy.  If you boil that sugar even two degrees too hot you end up with a hard, rock candy coating on the sides of the bowl that has to be chipped away before you can start all over.   Once the meringue is made you can whisk in the fruit puree and pour it into the 8 inch springform pans that you have lined with parchment paper.  Then it goes into the freezer for two hours.  Of course you can’t really start on the next layer right away because you have to wait until the first layer is frozen before you can pour the next one on to it.  I started drinking adult beverages pretty early on this day.  Total active time: 3-4 hours.


Sunday: The layers are frozen, one pan has three layers, the other pan has two.  Now I have to ease the pans off, peel off the parchment, and stack the two together to make one 5 layer stack.  This part was the part I was most dreading.  I imagined the whole thing sliding onto the floor and splattering the kitchen with kiwi meringue.  Surprisingly this was one of the easiest parts of the process.  The frozen layers released easily from the pan, the parchment peeled right off, and I was able to stack the cake onto its serving platter with ease.


The whole thing went into the freezer while I made the frosting.  Seven minute frosting gets its name from the seven minutes it takes to beat the mixture to the correct glossy, stiff consistency.  You start out the same as the other meringues: sugar/water/corn syrup heat to 23o degrees this time.  Beat into a bowl of frothy egg whites with a little more sugar.  The end product is not unlike marshmallow fluff.  With the frosting made I got the cake out and began to slather it on.  Wait a second….is this wrong?  There are bits of the strawberry layer coming off into the frosting and marring the glossy-white perfection!  And, hold on…this isn’t working…it’s not going to cover it.  Are you kidding?  This isn’t enough G** d**n f-ing seven minute frosting to cover the cake?!  The recipe says it makes 4 cups, enough to frost a 5-layer, 8 inch cake.  Well, it’s wrong.  I had to put the cake back into the freezer, and go back and make a second batch of frosting.  Once that was done, I quickly finished frosting the cake and stored it in the freezer for the party that night.  Active time on day three: 2 hours


I brought the cake out – the requisite “oohs” and “ahhs” were uttered.  I cut the cake, and there was that rainbow slice of perfection I had been fantasizing about.  Everyone loved the cake.  It looked great (I thought it looked better than it tasted) and a good time was had by all.  The birthday girl loved it, and that’s what mattered.  Although I will never, ever, EVER, make this cake again, I will never ever forget it.   Here is a link to the actual recipe should you choose to ignore my warnings and try to make it yourself.  If you do make one, take a picture and send it to me, and I will send you a surprise!



About swellkid recipes

I am a mother of two boys, a wife, a teacher, and an avid home cook. These recipes are written, tested and created or adapted by me in my home kitchen. All photos were taken by me with my Canon Digital Rebel XT. No filters or Photoshop, usually natural light on my kitchen table. My motto is, if I can do it, you can do it!
This entry was posted in Dessert and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

26 Responses to Frozen Rainbow Chiffon Cake – DO NOT ATTEMPT!

  1. I’ll stick to a single layer! We once made one of her drinks and it was so strong it gave me a headache. Katherine couldn’t finish hers so I had two, but still… a headache from two g**d*** drinks!

  2. Grandma Karen says:

    Beautiful rainbow cake. Is there any left???

  3. Chris macca says:

    Swellkid, you are amazing. I wish I was the birthday girl. No, I won’t ask you to make this on my birthday but I would like to try that fresh pineapple upside down cake. How long would that take?

  4. Brennan says:

    The birthday girl absolutely felt the love! The cake was amazing! I promise to never ever ask you to make it again!!! The whole party was spectacular and magical. I am so lucky to have a best friend like you and you in my corner. I am truly blessed!

  5. Kristi Brown says:

    This is the funniest review of a recipe I’ve ever read!

  6. Jen Reed says:

    Bravo to you, Carrie! This was utterly hilarious and fun to read. Sounds like a huge pain, but totally worth it. What a lucky friend you have!

  7. Stephanie says:

    whoa, that’s seriously incredible. i always seem to fall in love with martha stewart recipes, but many of them are so complex! i have to remind myself that she has a team of like 23498 people who also help her make stuff…haha! but wow, i probably would have given up after layer two. great job! looks amazing! 🙂

  8. Nikki says:

    Wow, I would’ve given up. But it really is so pretty!

  9. Nola says:

    I am two layers into this adventure into cakedom (or d**n cake). I wish I had seen your post first so I could have figured out the parchment paper easier.

  10. Kristine says:

    I made it this weekend for my own birthday adn the 1/2 birthday of my daughter. I agree that it takes a lot of time and effort – 2 days. The sense of accomplishment of a super tall cake is nearly worth it. Your’s turned out a bit better than mine. The kiwi layer never froze (improper syrup temp?) so the colors were out of order since I had to put that one on top. I didn’t mind because the orange and blue were then next to each other (Auburn University colors). I made the purees and layers one at a time. If I ever get the courage to do this again, I’ll use your method of pre-puree-ing.

  11. Pingback: Chocolate Cake with Salted Caramel (or another bleeping Martha cake) | swellkid

  12. Wow. You are a talented baker. But then again, this cake didn’t test your baking talents, but rather your patience, which you have much of too. Hats off.

  13. Juno says:

    I came across your blog whilst I was making this cake half way! I did the whole pre-purée thing too … My cake didn’t look as nice as yours but I totally got your point of of the amount of effort and time taken! I made it for a one – year old, bless him, don’t think he knew any difference but the parents and guests seems pretty happy about it! 🙂

  14. Stav says:

    Thanks for the warning.
    Could you tell me if it’s oC or oF.
    Many thanks

  15. Julia says:

    Thanks to your advice, I made a great cake with less fuss and muss. How can I send you some pics?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s